Findings

What Bad Reviews Are Actually About

Price, how staff behaved, and how a problem was handled: the themes that fill one- and two-star reviews, counted.

By Pulse of Reviews · 19 October 2026 · Based on 45,851 Google reviews of 244 businesses

In short

  • About 5 in every 100 Google reviews give one or two stars: 2,421 of 45,851.
  • Pricing is raised in 38% of those bad reviews and staff courtesy in 37%; communication and the handling of a problem each appear in about a quarter.
  • Two themes set bad reviews apart from good ones: pricing (38% of bad reviews, 14% of five-star ones) and how a problem was handled (25% against 2%).
  • Staff courtesy is the most raised theme in bad and good reviews alike, and it is negative in only 4.3% of its mentions.
  • How a problem was handled is the most contested theme: negative in 42% of its mentions.

Bad reviews are rare. Of 45,851 Google reviews of local businesses, 2,421 gave one or two stars: about 5 in every 100.

One- and two-star reviews, out of every 100

5 gave one or two stars95 gave three stars or more

2,421 of 45,851 reviews (5.3%).

They are rare, but they are read. In a Pew Research Center survey, 82% of US adults said they at least sometimes read online ratings or reviews before buying something for the first time. And 2,073 of them come with a written comment explaining what went wrong, usually at some length. We labelled each of those comments with the themes it discusses. This is what they are about.

Price leads, but only just

What one- and two-star comments discuss Share of the 2,073 written one- and two-star reviews that raise each theme
Pricing and fees 38%
Staff courtesy 37%
Communication 27%
Handling problems 25%
Scheduling and punctuality 13%

A comment can raise several themes, so the shares add up to more than 100%. Themes that apply to one trade only, such as food or pain relief, are left out here.

Pricing and fees is raised in 38% of bad reviews, more than any other theme. Staff courtesy is close behind at 37%. Then come communication and the way a problem was handled, each in about a quarter.

Notice what is not on top. Scheduling and punctuality, which covers lateness and missed appointments, appears in only 13% of bad reviews. A bad review is more often about money and manners than about time.

The same themes fill good reviews, with two exceptions

A list of what bad reviews discuss is only half the picture, because good reviews discuss many of the same things. The useful question is which themes turn up far more in bad reviews than in good ones.

How often each theme is raised: bad reviews beside five-star reviews Share of written reviews that raise the theme

One- and two-star reviewsFive-star reviews

Pricing and fees 38% 14%
Staff courtesy 37% 51%
Communication 27% 21%
Handling problems 25% 2%
Scheduling and punctuality 13% 16%

Based on 2,073 one- and two-star and 32,171 five-star reviews that include a comment.

Staff courtesy is the most raised theme in both. It appears in 51% of five-star comments and 37% of bad ones. How people were treated is what reviews are mostly about, whichever way the experience went.

Pricing is different. It comes up in 38% of bad reviews and only 14% of five-star ones. Happy customers seldom mention what they paid. Unhappy ones often do.

Handling problems is the sharpest divide of all. It is in 25% of bad reviews and 2% of five-star reviews. When a review talks about how a business dealt with something that went wrong, it is very likely a bad review. Something went wrong either way; the review is about what happened next. That theme has an article to itself: how a problem is handled.

Some themes are praised or criticised; some are fought over

Looking across all 36,209 written reviews, good and bad together, each theme can be scored on one question: when it is raised, how often is it raised as a complaint?

How often a theme is raised negatively Share of all mentions of the theme that are negative. Themes with at least 500 mentions.
Handling problems 42%
Table service * 21.4%
Atmosphere * 20.7%
Pricing and fees 19.6%
Fixed first time * 17.6%
Honest assessment * 11.8%
Food * 11.2%
Communication 8.7%
Scheduling and punctuality 6.8%
Quality of care * 6.1%
Staff courtesy 4.3%
Bedside manner * 3.7%
Emergency response * 3.6%
Treatment approach * 2.1%
Pain relief * 1%

* A theme used for some trades only: table service, atmosphere and food for restaurants; pain relief, treatment approach and bedside manner for health practices; fixed first time and honest assessment for repair trades.

Handling problems is negative in 42% of its 1,293 mentions. No other theme comes close. At the other end, pain relief is negative in 1% of 2,678 mentions: when a patient writes about whether the treatment eased their pain, it is nearly always to say that it did.

Staff courtesy sits low on this chart at 4.3%, even though it leads the list of what bad reviews discuss. Both are true. It is mentioned 17,597 times in all, so even a 4.3% negative share amounts to 764 complaints.

What to take from this

  • If you are choosing a business, look at what its bad reviews say about price and about how complaints were handled. Those are the two themes that separate bad reviews from good ones.
  • If you run a business, the review written after a problem is the one most at risk. In these reviews, how the problem was handled is criticised far more often than any other theme. Google lets a business reply publicly to its reviews, and report one that breaks its rules.
  • A complaint about rudeness is common but not telling on its own. Courtesy is the most discussed theme everywhere, and almost always favourably.

Sources and further reading

Browse the businesses we cover