The Four-Star Review: What Holds Back the Fifth Star
Four stars is the quietest rating. It is short, often wordless, nearly always positive in tone, and it still leaves a star on the table.
In short
- 2,568 of the reviews we hold give four stars: 5.6% of the total.
- Only 56% of four-star reviews include a comment, against 80% of five-star reviews, and the typical comment is 89 characters long.
- 91% of four-star comments are positive in tone. Just 11 of 1,434 are negative.
- Yet 29% of four-star comments criticise at least one thing, against 1% of five-star comments.
- Price is the most common reservation, raised negatively in 7.8% of four-star comments.
A four-star review is a satisfied customer holding something back. It is the least talkative rating on the scale, and it is worth knowing how to read, because the missing star is usually explained somewhere in it.
The quietest rating
Four starsFive stars
2,568 four-star reviews; 1,434 include a comment.
44% of four-star reviewers leave the stars and say nothing. Those who do write are brief.
89 characters is a sentence. A five-star reviewer typically writes 154, and an unhappy one writes far more: see unhappy customers write more.
Positive in tone, with a reservation
Read as a whole, a four-star comment is a happy one: 91% are positive in tone and almost none are negative. But tone and content are different things. A comment can be warm overall and still say that one thing was not right.
That is the difference between the two ratings. Almost no five-star comment contains a criticism. 29% of four-star comments do.
What costs the fifth star
* Themes used for restaurants and cafes only. They rank high here because restaurants receive many four-star reviews.
Price comes first: 7.8% of four-star comments say something critical about what was charged. The service was good, the reviewer says, but it was not cheap. In restaurants, the reservations are about the service at the table and the room more than about the food.
None of these is a large share. Most four-star comments criticise nothing at all, and the star was withheld for a reason the reviewer did not write down. For the themes behind the lowest ratings, see what bad reviews are actually about.
How to read a four-star review
- Treat it as a positive review. In tone, 91% are. A business with many four-star ratings has satisfied customers.
- Look for the "but". When a four-star comment does name a reservation, it is specific, and it is from someone with no grudge. That makes it some of the most reliable criticism a business receives.
- Do not read much into silence. A four-star rating with no comment tells you the customer was content and nothing more.
- If you run a business, four-star comments are where to look for what to improve. A business can reply to its reviews on Google, and a reply that acknowledges the reservation is read by the next customer.
Sources and further reading
- Online reviews and ratings, Pew Research Center, 2016. A US survey of how people read and weigh online reviews.
- Manage customer reviews, Google Business Profile Help. How a business can read and reply to its reviews.