Home Services Reviews: What Goes Right and What Goes Wrong
Plumbers, electricians, roofers, painters and the other trades that work at your home: what their customers praise and what they complain about.
In short
- We counted 9,802 Google reviews of 90 businesses in 12 home trades, such as plumbers, electricians, HVAC and roofing contractors.
- 94.9% gave five stars; 2.9% gave one or two.
- What customers praise: staff courtesy (in 53% of comments), scheduling and punctuality (37%) and communication (36%).
- What they complain about: pricing is raised in 54% of the one- and two-star comments, communication in 40%.
- Punctuality is raised negatively in only 2.8% of its mentions.
Hiring someone to work on your home means letting a stranger in, on a day you may have taken off work, to fix something you cannot inspect. It is the kind of purchase people read reviews for. This is what 9,802 of those reviews say.
Which trades, and how many reviews
Home trades here means work done at the customer's property: plumbing, electrical and solar, heating and cooling, roofing, painting, general contracting, landscaping, fencing, pest control, cleaning, flooring, pools, windows and doors, damage restoration, appliance repair and smart home services.
What goes right: people, timing, communication
A comment can raise several themes, so the shares add up to more than 100%.
53% of the comments are about how the workers behaved. After that come two things specific to having someone come to your home: whether they arrived when they said they would (37% of comments) and whether they kept the customer informed (36%).
Timing is not where these businesses lose customers. Scheduling and punctuality is raised 3,114 times and is negative in 2.8% of them. Customers mention timing mostly to say the crew came on time, or came the same day.
What goes wrong: the price
Bad reviews are scarce here: 288 of 9,802 gave one or two stars, and 254 of those explain why.
Pricing is in 54% of the bad reviews, well ahead of anything else. Across all home services reviews, good and bad, price is raised negatively in 9.7% of its mentions, against 2.8% for punctuality and 1.8% for staff courtesy. The complaint is seldom that the work was bad. Workmanship is negative in 2.8% of its mentions. It is that the work cost more than the customer thought fair, or more than they were first told.
Communication (40%) and the way a problem was handled (33%) follow. Put together, an unhappy home services review is usually about a surprise on the invoice and nobody returning the call. Across all kinds of business, how a problem is handled is the theme customers are most divided on.
Trade by trade
Plumbers: 9 businesses, 3,082 reviews; Electricians & Solar: 14 businesses, 1,965 reviews; HVAC Contractors: 8 businesses, 1,430 reviews; Roofing Contractors: 10 businesses, 751 reviews; Landscapers & Tree Services: 6 businesses, 581 reviews; General Contractors & Remodelers: 14 businesses, 507 reviews; Window & Door Contractors: 9 businesses, 494 reviews; Painters: 8 businesses, 461 reviews.
The differences between trades are small and should not be read as a ranking: each rests on a handful of businesses, and one business with a run of bad reviews moves its trade's figure. What the chart does show is that in every trade here, low ratings are a small minority.
What to take from this
- If you are hiring, expect near-perfect ratings: among these businesses they are the rule. Read the low reviews for what they say about price, and ask for the price in writing before work begins. The US Federal Trade Commission publishes guidance on hiring a contractor.
- If you run a home services business, your customers already notice punctuality and say so. The reviews you lose are lost on the invoice: a clear estimate, and a call before the cost changes, address the largest group of complaints.
Sources and further reading
- How To Avoid a Home Improvement Scam, Consumer Advice, US Federal Trade Commission. Official guidance for anyone hiring a contractor.
- Online reviews and ratings, Pew Research Center, 2016. A US survey of how people use online reviews before buying.