Unhappy Customers Write More: What Review Length Tells You
A typical one-star Google review is twice as long as a five-star one, and the longer a review runs, the likelier it is a complaint.
In short
- A typical one-star Google review is 307 characters long; a typical five-star review is 154.
- Four-star reviews say least: the typical one is 89 characters, and only 56% include a comment at all.
- 18.7% of comments of 600 characters or more come with one or two stars, against 3.3% of comments under 100 characters.
- A negative comment raises 2.3 themes on average; a positive one raises 1.6.
- Based on 45,851 Google reviews of 244 local businesses.
People who leave one star have more to say than people who leave five. Across 45,851 Google reviews of local businesses, the typical one-star comment runs to 307 characters. The typical five-star comment runs to 154: about half the length.
Based on 1,649 one-star and 32,171 five-star reviews that include a comment.
"Typical" here means the median: half of the comments are longer and half are shorter. Averages tell the same story more loudly, because a few very long complaints pull the one-star average up to 496 characters, against 225 for five stars.
Length falls as the stars rise, with one exception
Set the five ratings side by side and the pattern is a slope. One- and two-star comments are the longest. Three stars is shorter. The shortest of all is not five stars but four.
A four-star comment is typically 89 characters, little more than a sentence. A five-star reviewer is enthusiastic and says why. A one-star reviewer is aggrieved and says why at length. The four-star reviewer is satisfied, and satisfaction does not need much explaining. We look at that rating on its own in the four-star review.
Who bothers to explain at all
Not every review comes with words. Some are stars and nothing else. Whether a reviewer adds a comment depends heavily on the rating they give.
1,903 one-star, 518 two-star, 855 three-star, 2,568 four-star and 40,007 five-star reviews.
87% of one-star reviews carry a comment. So do 80% of five-star reviews. In the middle the words dry up: only 56% of four-star reviews and 62% of three-star reviews say anything. The strongest opinions, in either direction, are the ones people put into words.
The longer the comment, the likelier it is a complaint
Turn the question around. Instead of asking how long a bad review is, ask how often a long review is bad.
12,418 reviews under 100; 14,686 reviews 100 to 299; 6,368 reviews 300 to 599; 2,737 reviews 600 or more.
Among comments under 100 characters, 3.3% come with one or two stars. Among comments of 600 characters or more, 18.7% do: more than 5 times as often. Most long reviews are still happy ones, because happy reviews outnumber unhappy ones many times over. But a long review is where the complaints are concentrated.
Readers seem to sense this already. In a Pew Research Center survey of people in the United States who read online reviews, 54% said they pay more attention to extremely negative reviews than to extremely positive ones.
Complaints also cover more ground
Length is not only repetition. We label each comment with the themes it discusses, such as pricing, punctuality or how staff behaved. A negative comment raises more of them.
Based on 2,250 negative and 33,433 positive comments.
Praise tends to be about one thing: the person was kind, the job was done well. A complaint is more often a list, in which the price, the delay and the way the problem was handled each get a mention. Which themes fill that list is the subject of what bad reviews are actually about.
None of this would surprise a psychologist. A much-cited review of the research, “Bad Is Stronger Than Good”, argues that bad experiences leave a deeper mark than good ones and are thought about for longer. Our counts cannot say why unhappy customers write more; they are consistent with that idea.
What to take from this
- If you are reading reviews before choosing a business, the long ones are worth your time. They are where specific problems are described, and there are few enough of them to read in full.
- If you run a business, a long one-star review is unusually detailed feedback. It usually names several separate things that went wrong, not one.
- A four-star rating tells you least. 44% of four-star reviews come with no comment at all, and those that have one are the shortest.
Sources and further reading
- Online reviews and ratings, Pew Research Center, 2016. A US survey of how people use reviews. Among those who read them, 54% said they pay more attention to extremely negative reviews.
- Bad Is Stronger Than Good, Baumeister, Bratslavsky, Finkenauer and Vohs, Review of General Psychology, 2001. A review of psychology research arguing that bad events weigh more heavily on people than good ones.