How a Problem Is Handled: The Theme That Divides Customers Most
Of everything customers write about, the way a business deals with something going wrong is the theme most often raised as a complaint.
In short
- Customers wrote about how a business handled a problem in 1,293 reviews: 740 times positively and 543 times negatively.
- At 42% negative, it is the most contested of the themes that apply to every business. The next, pricing and fees, is at 19.6%.
- When the handling is praised, 93% of those reviews give five stars. When it is criticised, 92% give one or two.
- The theme appears in 25% of one- and two-star comments and 2% of five-star comments.
- A complaint about handling usually comes with others: pricing and fees in 46% of those reviews and communication in 42%.
Things go wrong in every business. A part is late, a bill is wrong, a job has to be redone. What customers write about afterwards is less the fault than the response. We label that theme "handling problems", and no theme divides customers more.
The most contested theme there is
Handling problems 1,293, Pricing and fees 5,590, Communication 7,438, Scheduling and punctuality 5,682, Staff courtesy 17,597 mentions.
Staff courtesy is mentioned 17,597 times and is negative in 4.3% of them: people mostly bring it up to say thank you. Handling problems is mentioned far less often, 1,293 times, and is negative in 42%.
It cuts both ways, and cleanly
42% negative also means 57.2% positive. More often than not, when a customer writes about a problem, it is to say that it was put right. And the stars follow the handling almost exactly.
These are reviews in which something went wrong. In 740 of them the customer was satisfied with the response, and 93% of those still gave five stars. A problem that is handled well does not cost a business its rating. In these reviews it reads as a reason for the rating.
Where the response was criticised, 92% gave one or two stars and none gave five. Hardly anyone in either group settled on four stars: 4% of the first and 1% of the second.
It lives in bad reviews
25% of bad reviews discuss it. Hardly any five-star reviews do, for the simple reason that most five-star customers had no problem to be handled. So although the theme is praised more often than criticised, it is far more prominent in the reviews a business would rather not have. The other themes that fill those reviews are set out in what bad reviews are actually about.
Those are also the reviews that get read. In a Pew Research Center survey, 54% of people in the United States who read online reviews said they pay more attention to extremely negative ones.
A mishandled problem rarely comes alone
46% of these reviews also complain about pricing and fees, 42% about communication and 40% about staff courtesy. That is what a mishandled problem looks like from the customer's side: nobody called back, the person who did was curt, and the bill did not change. The same pattern shows in reviews of home services.
What to take from this
- If you are choosing a business, search its reviews for what happened when something went wrong. A business with a few reviews praising how it fixed a mistake has shown you something a spotless record cannot.
- If you run a business, the response matters more than the fault. In these reviews, customers whose problem was handled well were as generous with stars as customers who never had one.
- A public reply is part of the handling. Google lets a business reply to its reviews, where future customers will read the answer, and report a review that breaks its rules.
Sources and further reading
- Manage customer reviews, Google Business Profile Help. How a business can read and reply to the reviews on its Google listing.
- Report inappropriate reviews on your Business Profile, Google Business Profile Help. What a business can do about a review that breaks Google's rules.
- Online reviews and ratings, Pew Research Center, 2016. A US survey: among people who read reviews, 54% said they pay more attention to extremely negative ones.